Zhaoyang District Mother Deer Lotus Shantytown Renovation and Resettlement (Plot 1 and 2) Construction Project Whole Process Tracking Audit Bidding Candidate

Announcement of winning candidates

Bidding Project Name: Zhaoyang District Mother Deer Lotus Shantytown Renovation and Resettlement (Plot 1 and 2) Construction Project Whole Process Tracking Audit Bidding

Lot No.: GC530600202300694001001 Lot Name: Zhaoyang District Mother Deer Lotus Shantytown Renovation and Resettlement (Plot 1 and 2) Construction Project Whole Process Tracking Audit Bidding

Bid Inviter: Resident Committee of Mulu Community, Fenghuang Street, Zhaoyang District, Zhaotong City. Address of the Bid Inviter: Group 6, Mulu Community, South Section of Second Ring West Road, Zhaoyang District

Bidding contact person: Ni Qing Contact phone number: 13908707609

Tendering Agent: Yunnan Zhongzi Overseas Consulting Co., Ltd. Tendering Agent Address: 107, Building G, Hongfa Jindu, Second Ring South Road, Zhaoyang District

Bidding agent contact person: Yang Renhong Bidding agent contact phone number: 13087480585

Classification of Public Resource Trading Industry: Housing Construction Engineering Type: Other

Estimated contract price (10000 yuan): 93428.31 Bid opening time: 09:30, November 22, 2023

Barrier price (rate or unit price, etc.): 1. Cost control throughout the construction phase, basic cost for project settlement review: 3 ‰ of the construction and installation project cost; 2. Financial settlement audit service fee: According to the "Implementation Measures for Service Fee Management of Yunnan Province Accounting Firms" and the "Audit Service Fee Standards of Yunnan Province Accounting Firms", the service fee is calculated based on a downward floating rate and shall not rise. 3. Effectiveness Surcharge (amount beyond 5% of the approved cost for audit differences): 5% of the reduced amount (amount within 5% of the approved cost for audit differences shall not be counted as effectiveness surcharge). \Supervision department and contact information: Zhaoyang District Housing and Urban Rural Development Bureau 0870-3193147

Publication start time: 09:00, November 23, 2023 Publication end time: 17:00, November 27, 2023

Bidding method: Public bidding and evaluation method: Comprehensive evaluation method

Whether the evaluation results are publicly announced: Public announcement Nature: Normal

Description of the proposed winning bidder:

Bid evaluation situation: see attachment for details

Objections, complaints, supervision channels, and other contents: In accordance with the provisions of the "Tendering and Bidding Law of the People's Republic of China" and relevant laws and regulations, the bidding results of this project are now publicly announced and subject to social supervision. If there is any objection to the above publicity, in accordance with Article 54 of the Implementation Regulations of the Tendering and Bidding Law of the People's Republic of China, bidders may raise objections to the tenderer during the publicity period; If the bidder is dissatisfied with the objection response, they may file a written complaint in real name with the relevant administrative supervision department in accordance with Article 60 of the Implementation Regulations of the Tendering and Bidding Law of the People's Republic of China and Articles 3 and 7 of the Complaints Handling Measures for Engineering Construction Project Tendering and Bidding Activities. \Administrative supervision department phone number: 0870-3193147.

Bid winning candidate information

First winning candidate: Yongdao Engineering Consulting (Jiangsu) Co., Ltd

Unit code: 9132010274821886XF

Consortium bidding unit: Yunnan Yongsheng Certified Public Accountants

Consortium bidding unit code: 91530112665547932D

Proposed winning bidder: Yes

Bid evaluation ranking: 1

Price type: rate or unit price, etc

Quotation: (1) Basic cost for cost control throughout the construction phase and engineering settlement review: 2.30 ‰ of the construction and installation engineering cost; (2) Financial settlement review service fee: a decrease of 1.50%; (3) Effect surcharge: 5.00% of the reduced amount

Score: 83.6

Project leader: Wang Changjin

Name and number of relevant certificates for project leader: First level registered cost engineer Jian [Zao] 02320002960

Performance of project leader:

Construction period (delivery time): From the date of signing the contract, it shall be implemented until the completion of all cost consultation contents agreed within the bidding scope of this project, which shall be reviewed by the reviewing unit and terminated after issuing an audit report

Quality: Comply with current national, local, and industry standards and specifications, ensure the completeness, truthfulness, accuracy, clarity, and evidence of the results, and meet the requirements proposed by the tenderer for this project, in accordance with the audit requirements of the audit department

Qualification and capability requirements for responding to the bidding documents

Qualification level of the bidder: engineering cost consulting qualification, accounting firm practice certificate

Reputation requirement: Fully respond to the bidding documents

Similar performance of enterprises: fully responsive to bidding documents

Safety Production License: Fully responsive to the bidding documents

Candidate for the second winning bid: Shenzhen Qulun Project Management Co., Ltd

Unit code: 91440113068175368R

Consortium bidding unit: Yunnan Qinghui Certified Public Accountants (general partnership)

Consortium bidding unit code: 91530100MA6QCYNU1E

Proposed winning bidder: No

Bid evaluation ranking: 2

Price type: rate or unit price, etc

Quotation: (1) Basic cost for cost control throughout the construction phase and engineering settlement review: 2.35 ‰ of the construction and installation engineering cost; (2) Financial settlement review service fee: a decrease of 1.00%; (3) Effect surcharge: 4.98% of the reduced amount

Score: 81.82

Project leader: Liu Yunguo

Name and number of relevant certificates for project leader: First level registered cost engineer Jian [Zao] 11054400010050

Performance of project leader:

Construction period (delivery time): From the date of signing the contract, it shall be implemented until the completion of all cost consultation contents agreed within the bidding scope of this project, which shall be reviewed by the reviewing unit and terminated after issuing an audit report

Quality: Comply with current national, local, and industry standards and specifications, ensure the completeness, truthfulness, accuracy, clarity, and evidence of the results, and meet the requirements proposed by the tenderer for this project, in accordance with the audit requirements of the audit department

Qualification and capability requirements for responding to the bidding documents

Qualification level of the bidder: engineering cost consulting qualification, accounting firm practice certificate

Reputation requirement: Fully respond to the bidding documents

Similar performance of enterprises: fully responsive to bidding documents

Safety Production License: Fully responsive to the bidding documents

Candidate for the third winning bid: Yunnan Shengxu Engineering Project Management Co., Ltd

Unit code: 91530100MA6KAKLF1T

JV Bidder: Sichuan Prin Certified Public Accountants Co., Ltd

Consortium bidding unit code: 91510000686135654L

Proposed winning bidder: No

Bid evaluation ranking: 3

Price type: rate or unit price, etc

Quotation: (1) Basic cost for cost control throughout the construction phase and engineering settlement review: 2.10 ‰ of the construction and installation engineering cost; (2) Financial settlement review service fee: a decrease of 25.00%; (3) Effect surcharge: 3.50% of the reduced amount

Score: 78.33

Project leader: Zhou Lizhen

Name and number of relevant certificates for project leader: First level registered cost engineer Jian [Zao] 11195300007220

Performance of project leader:

Construction period (delivery time): From the date of signing the contract, it shall be implemented until the completion of all cost consultation contents agreed within the bidding scope of this project, which shall be reviewed by the reviewing unit and terminated after issuing an audit report

Quality: Comply with current national, local, and industry standards and specifications, ensure the completeness, truthfulness, accuracy, clarity, and evidence of the results, and meet the requirements proposed by the tenderer for this project, in accordance with the audit requirements of the audit department

Qualification and capability requirements for responding to the bidding documents

Qualification level of the bidder: engineering cost consulting qualification, accounting firm practice certificate

Reputation requirement: Fully respond to the bidding documents

Similar performance of enterprises: fully responsive to bidding documents

Safety Production License: Fully responsive to the bidding documents

Detailed rating table:

SN File Name Creation Time

1 Detailed scoring table_ Attachment. pdf 2023-11-22 13:35:33